I have a confession to make. My morning news of choice is MSNBC's "Morning Joe." I know, I know...but in my opinion they have the most well rounded group and I do enjoy the format and humor. Plus, I like to keep up on the way the "other side" spins events.
Anyway, Joe Scarbourough made a comment this morning that I caught in passing that I found interesting. He stated that there is a misconception that in American politics the people are a pendulum that swings from right to left. He contended that this was false, that America always stays "center" and it's the politicians that move the pendulum and whenever it gets too far to one side the people will force it back. It reminded me of a Milton Friedman quote:
“I do not believe that the solution to our problem is simply to elect the right people. The important thing is to establish a political climate of opinion which will make it politically profitable for the wrong people to do the right thing. Unless it is politically profitable for the wrong people to do the right thing, the right people will not do the right thing either, or if they try, they will shortly be out of office.”
The first time I came across this quote was in my friend Isaac Morehouse's blog post where he was making the case that elections don't matter. It is a very good (and quick) post and well worth the read, as is most of his writing.
Now I am sure this congress believed that what they were doing was the right thing, but America did not so they were "shortly out of office" courtesy of "the center." But what IS the center? Can the center move? If it can't then we are stuck and we will never be any more or less free. How depressing is that?
I agree with Isaac's point that ideas are the most important thing and that what gets done is dependent on what ideas have taken root; however, I disagree that elections don't matter. I think the Ron Paul 2008 presidential run proved that. His campaign has done more to advance ideas concerning liberty than Cato, Reason, Mises, etc combined. So elections CAN matter, but sadly they often don't. I don't believe that education/ideas and politics have to be in two separate compartments, they are intertwined and influence each other.
The point I'm trying to make is that Scarbourough only got it half right. Indeed, like Friedman alluded, our government won't be able to do anything more than what "the center" is comfortable with. But the center can, and does, move through education (which can happen with or without politics). So Joe, there are two pendulums in American politics and they work with and against each other.
Recent Comments